It seems that my speculation that the unnatural outbound link manual actions sent over the weekend were related to Google’s recent warning to bloggers about using followed links for paid reviews is accurate. Many, if not all, of the targeted sites are blogs and it is becoming apparent that they seem to have compensated reviews without using a nofollow in common.
Now paid and compensated reviews can come in many forms, including where the product was free or discounted in exchange for a review or even a mere mention with a link. And the links don’t just refer to links to the company or product page, but can include links to social media accounts, retailers and affiliate links. And while linking to these external pages is fine, they must be nofollowed to meet Google’s webmaster guidelines. And it is also worth noting that these pages should have a disclaimer about the reviews as well.
Google’s John Mueller responded to some of the active threads in the Webmaster Help forums about these manual actions, and both were about the issue of links in paid reviews.
Here is the first one:
For many of the sites that posted about this message recently, Travler’s link (thanks!) is spot on: https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2016/03/best-practices-for-bloggers-reviewing.html (this was also shared on other Google blogs)
In particular, if a post was made because of a free product (or free service, or just paid, etc), then any links placed there because of that need to have a rel=nofollow attached to them. This includes links to the product itself, any sales pages (such as on Amazon), affiliate links, social media profiles, etc. that are associated with that post. Additionally, I imagine your readers would also appreciate it if those posts were labeled appropriately. It’s fine to keep these kinds of posts up, sometimes there’s a lot of useful information in them! However, the links in those posts specifically need to be modified so that they don’t pass PageRank (by using the rel=nofollow).Once these links are cleaned up appropriately, feel free to submit a reconsideration request, so that the webspam team can double-check and remove the manual action.
This one was a response in a thread where the webmaster shared their site that received a manual action, and again, compensated reviews was the culprit.
From a quick check, it looks like you removed the post I noticed on your site, so I guess at least that one’s cleaned up. Travler mentioned (thanks!) the relevant link here: https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2016/03/best-practices-for-bloggers-reviewing.html (this was also shared on other Google blogs)
In general, when you’re getting a free product (or service, etc) in exchange for a post, you need to make sure that the links there are nofollowed — be it to the original product page, a sales page or affiliate link on a site like Amazon, or to their social media profiles. You don’t need to nofollow everything on your blog, just the links that are involved in an exchange like this. Obviously, it’s also good to disclose this kind of relationship to your readers too — on the page I was looking at, you did that already, but others might not be doing that.
Once you’ve cleaned up these kinds of outbound links by adding a nofollow where appropriate, feel free to submit a reconsideration request ( https://support.google.com/
webmasters/answer/35843 ) so that it can be reviewed by our webspam folks & so that they can remove this manual action on your site.
And another post:
It looks like you’re getting some good advice here already (thanks, everyone!). Travler’s link – https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2016/03/best-practices-for-bloggers-reviewing.html – is one you should really be going through (in addition to the more general webmaster guidelines). There’s absolutely no need to nofollow every link on your site! However, those that are there because of an exchange (such as a product or service for a review) should have a rel=nofollow on links to the product, to their sales pages, and to any social media profiles that are linked because of the review. Also, it’s always a good idea to clearly label these kinds of posts for your readers too.
Once you’ve cleaned up links like those, feel free to submit a reconsideration request through Search Console, so that the webspam team can review your changes and remove the manual action. More on that at https://support.google.com/
webmasters/answer/35843
Of course, there are other types of links, such as badges, link parties and link exchanges that could definitely fall under this manual action (and if those types of links are present, it could cause the reconsideration request to be denied), but it seems likely that the culprit is followed links to companies (including their social profiles and affiliate links) in exchange for products/reviews are the ones that triggered these manual actions in the first place. So nofollow these links to meet Google’s webmaster guidelines.
Jennifer Slegg
Latest posts by Jennifer Slegg (see all)
- 2022 Update for Google Quality Rater Guidelines – Big YMYL Updates - August 1, 2022
- Google Quality Rater Guidelines: The Low Quality 2021 Update - October 19, 2021
- Rethinking Affiliate Sites With Google’s Product Review Update - April 23, 2021
- New Google Quality Rater Guidelines, Update Adds Emphasis on Needs Met - October 16, 2020
- Google Updates Experiment Statistics for Quality Raters - October 6, 2020